Mutual Spec Console

q -> theta -> s | ledger msg-a591202ae79c

Spec: needs user clarification Verifier: blocked Gate: analysis ready Route: sync path

Task Signal

idle

Platform State

Ready or active Optional or needs input Missing or blocked Running now Async/background job Human review gate
Ready
Mutual Specification Game ledger implemented in app/spec_state.py
Ready
Trader decision-state inference theta/q/s, evidence contract, decision_gate
Ready
Data-only IBKR/Yahoo evidence framing decision support only; no broker execution
Ready
P/Q/A formalization evaluator implemented in app/formalization.py
Ready
Async escalation jobs light route can enqueue strong/tool-heavy jobs
Ready
Multimodal artifact retrieval enabled by MULTIMODAL_RETRIEVAL_ENABLED
Ready
Resource-region domination telemetry BigQuery criteria layer for model-region routing
Ready
Live resource telemetry collectors mutual-spec-telemetry CLI for Asset, Monitoring, Billing, and power proxies
Ready
Vertex AI Gemini auth GOOGLE_GENAI_USE_VERTEXAI + project + location
Optional
Gemini API key fallback optional; Vertex AI auth is active
Ready
Cheap model gemini-3.5-flash
Ready
Strong model gemini-3.5-flash
Ready
Verifier model gemini-3.5-flash
Ready
Gemini multimodal embeddings gemini-embedding-001
Ready
Model Armor MODEL_ARMOR_TEMPLATE or TEMPLATE_ID
Ready
BigQuery analytics adk_agent_analytics
Ready
MCP research tools MCP_RESEARCH_URL or MCP_RESEARCH_COMMAND (+ OPOINT_API_KEY for Opoint)
Ready
Trader source layer Spanner RAG, Google search, google_cse keys, Vertex AI Search, or MCP/Opoint

Route Before Decision

The decision frame below is provisional until each required route step clears.

analysis ready
  1. 1
    Input captured Waiting

    User query and attached artifacts were accepted by the console.

  2. 2
    Shared spec inferred Complete

    goal=set, audience=set, format=set

  3. 3
    Sources and retrieval Running

    spanner_rag,mcp: not_applicable; cited items=0.

  4. 4
    Formal obligations Complete

    No missing formal obligations in the latest formalization pass.

  5. 5
    Verifier Blocked

    Verifier still has blocking findings.

  6. 6
    Human gate Not required

    No human-review gate applies to this request.

  7. 7
    Decision frame Provisional

    Decision gate is analysis ready; route mode is sync path.

Model Handoff Plan

This console records model selection per stage. Stages marked deterministic did not call a Gemini model in this request.

stagemodel classselected modelactual execution
No model route records yet.

Answer First / Provisional Decision Frame

This is the operator answer. Ledgers below explain why.

analysis ready

Immediate answer: use the current response as the working answer; the current best action is finalize.

No human-review gate.

This task is not currently blocked by high-stakes review policy.

  • Latent task: User wants a general executable task specification.
  • Current spec: goal=unresolved, audience=unresolved, format=unresolved.
  • Working answer: the submitted task
  • Source layer: not_applicable with 0 cited item(s); no cited evidence was retrieved for this run, so factual claims remain provisional.
  • Verification: blocked; decision gate=analysis ready; human review=not required.
  • Next action: finalize the answer with the cited evidence and accepted assumptions.
sources not_applicable / 0 human review not_required verification blocked

Alignment Loop

User and agent update the shared spec before the decision frame is trusted.

alignment 0.49
q

none

theta

User wants a general executable task specification.

s

goal=unresolved; audience=unresolved; format=unresolved

endorsed
none
pending
audience, goal, latent_task, output_format
rejected
none
last move
awaiting user signal

No alignment move submitted in this browser session.

Mutual Specification Game

convergence 0.49 / negotiating
  1. 1. Elicitation Cooperative partial-information game

    Infer latent task from compressed signal and artifacts.

  2. 2. Commitment Signaling game

    Commit to decision frame, evidence contract, and proof obligations.

  3. 3. Execution Graph Full-information graph game

    Route to search tools, model reasoning, verifier, model-region frontier, and async work if needed.

  4. 4. Gate Verification and budget condition

    Do not claim go/no-go until missing obligations are resolved.

Executable Stage State
  • elicitation cooperative_partial_information

    Recover theta from lossy query q with minimal user burden. Blocks: goal, audience, output_format

  • dialogue_commitment signaling_commitment_under_asymmetric_information

    Convert signals into explicit commitments and accepted assumptions. Blocks: goal, audience, output_format

  • mutual_alignment iterated_belief_update_game

    Let the user endorse, correct, or demand evidence for the inferred theta and shared spec. Blocks: latent_task

  • retrieval evidence_selection_game

    Select sources that reduce specification uncertainty. Blocks: none

  • execution_graph full_information_graph_game

    Run model, tool, verifier, async, and human-review nodes under explicit gates. Blocks: none

  • proof_obligations proof_carrying_response_game

    Reduce claims, evidence gaps, review requirements, and verifier findings to explicit proof work. Blocks: none

  • equilibrium_diagnostics multicriteria_action_dominance_game

    Identify which next actions are dominated under specification gain, risk reduction, burden, latency, and policy constraints. Blocks: none

  • verification adversarial_verification_game

    Block unsupported claims, unsafe paths, and specification gaming. Blocks: none

  • human_review skill_compatible_review_game

    Keep high-stakes decisions compatible with the user's skill, evidence, and decision ownership. Blocks: none

  • formal_proofs lean_gate_invariant_game

    Machine-check narrow logical gate invariants when Lean is available. Blocks: Lean executable is unavailable; generated checks are inspectable but not machine-checked.

Latent Type Beliefs
  • general_specification p=1.00 | next=ask

    User wants a general executable task specification. Signals: default prior

Claim Graph
  • inference supported | claim:68c39a57876d

    Latent type belief general_specification: User wants a general executable task specification. p=1.0

  • decision_gate unverified | claim:5915b5cf70dc

    Decision gate remains analysis_ready.

Trader Source Layer

spanner_rag,mcp / not_applicable
Source Adapters
  • No source adapters recorded.
Search Plan
  • No trader search plan.
Retrieved Evidence
  • No retrieved source evidence in this console run.

Proof Obligations

0 open
  • No proof obligations generated.

Equilibrium Diagnostics

finalize

Recommended action `finalize` because no hard conflicts remain.

actionspecriskburdenlatencypolicy
ask 0.25 0.15 0.65 0.10 0.00
retrieve 0.25 0.20 0.20 0.55 0.00
review 0.15 0.20 0.55 0.50 0.00
propose 0.55 0.35 0.30 0.20 0.00
finalize 0.35 0.20 0.10 0.10 0.00
defer 0.20 0.35 0.10 0.85 0.00
Conflicts
  • none

Formal Proof Checks

unavailable

Lean checks only narrow logical gate invariants. Market, logistics, sanctions, counterparty, and document claims remain empirical proof obligations.

backend
lean
lean
unavailable
  • finalization allowed when hard gates are clear / unavailable lean:b8aa2e294a80

    A spec can pass the formal finalize gate when no hard formal gates remain.

Shared Specification

analysis ready
q

theta
  • none
s

unresolved

audience

unresolved

format

unresolved

missing
  • none
Success Criteria
  • none

Model-Region Frontier

modelregionqualitylatency costspreadcarbontie
gemini-3.5-flash us-central1 0.000 80 0.010 0.020 0.000 80.080
gemini-3.5-flash us-south1 0.000 170 0.020 0.010 0.030 170.060
gemini-3.5-flash us-east4 0.000 260 0.030 0.020 0.060 260.110
gemini-3.5-flash-strong us-central1 0.060 80 0.020 0.020 0.000 80.150
gemini-3.5-flash-strong us-south1 0.060 170 0.030 0.010 0.030 170.130
gemini-3.5-flash-strong us-east4 0.060 260 0.040 0.020 0.060 260.180

Multimodal Evidence

  • No artifacts.
Artifact Evidence
  • none

Human Review Gate

Operator review is a gate decision. It does not override missing evidence or verifier obligations.

not required
No human-review gate.

This task is not currently blocked by high-stakes review policy.

No operator decision submitted in this browser session.

required
false
risk
low
assignee
human_reviewer
owner
user
Reasons
  • none
Required Actions
  • none
Blocking Claims
  • none
Blocking Evidence
  • none
Approval Conditions
  • No high-severity verifier findings remain.
  • Required evidence is retrieved, inspected, or explicitly waived with rationale.
  • Unsupported claim-graph nodes are supported, downgraded to assumptions, or removed.
  • The user remains final decision owner; the agent does not execute trades or broker actions.

Skill Compatibility

summarize
role
unknown
skill
unknown
domain
low
burden
low
depth
brief
handoff
proof_packet
Compatibility Risks
  • none
Evidence For Handoff
  • none
Learned From
  • current_query

Route Decision

mode
sync
risk
0
gain
low
  • low_risk_sync_path

Cost Proxy

tokens
800
token usd
0.000000
kWh
0.00017600
power usd
0.00001408